Skip to main content

Can I Get a Witness!

Faith, Family, and Chicago Gospel Music

The remarkable story of pastor Donald Gay and his family’s lasting contributions to gospel music and Chicago culture.

When the preacher Gregory Donald Gay joined his sisters onstage at Carnegie Hall in 1950, on a sold-out bill they shared with Mahalia Jackson and the Clara Ward Singers, he became a participant in a landmark moment: the first concert in the venue to feature entirely gospel music. He was just five years old.

The Gay Sisters—Evelyn, Geraldine, and Mildred—were key figures in gospel’s Golden Age, and their youngest brother had a front-row seat. Evelyn and Geraldine each innovated singular approaches to gospel piano, while Mildred sang. Together, they toured and performed on a series of influential gospel recordings from 1948 to 1973, playing the Apollo Theatre and crossing paths with musical luminaries like Sister Rosetta Tharpe, Sam Cooke, Pops Staples, and Dizzy Gillespie. But despite a hit record and prodigious talent, the Gay Sisters faded from the limelight. In the ensuing years, they weathered personal trials while their mother, Fannie, devoted her attention to another family undertaking: starting a church.

Can I Get a Witness! is a call-and-response between Steven B. Dolins, founder of The Sirens Records, and Donald Gay, who vividly describes his boyhood in Chicago’s Woodlawn neighborhood, his family’s remarkable place in gospel history, his mother’s work as a faith leader, and his own calling as a pastor. The book spotlights the rich contributions of a family remembered not only for the songs they recorded but also for their unwavering kindness to others, a legacy that the legendary Sonny Rollins recounts in a moving foreword.


304 pages | 26 halftones | 6 x 9 | © 2026

Chicago Visions and Revisions

Black Studies

Chicago and Illinois

History: American History

Music: General Music

Reviews

“Dolins has given readers a great gift—a behind-the-curtain view of the gospel music industry during its golden era. There’s no better docent for the journey than Pastor Donald Gay because he and his siblings, the famous Gay Sisters of Chicago, were ‘in the room where it happened.’ Pastor Gay’s gift for storytelling, his remarkable recall, wonderful sense of humor, and lifelong curiosity paint a very human portrait of the pioneers and legends of gospel music. His stories linger with you long after their telling.”

Robert M. Marovich, editor-in-chief of the Journal of Gospel Music

“The Gay family’s immense contributions to gospel and Chicago have been overlooked for far too long. Mildred, Evelyn, Geraldine, and Donald Gay helped forge the music’s golden age while selflessly uplifting their community on the South Side. Donald Gay’s vivid memory, sharp sense of humor and unflinching honesty set the record straight as Steven B. Dolins envelops the reverend’s brilliant personal narrative with crucial historical context. This vital book is a cause for celebration.”

Aaron Cohen, author of “Move On Up: Chicago Soul Music and Black Cultural Power”

“Dolins and Gay have crafted an extraordinary history on the sadly overlooked but hugely gifted 1950s era gospel trio, The Gay Sisters. Rev. Gay’s older sisters Evelyn, Geraldine, and Mildred Gay were the Destiny’s Child of their era on the gospel scene. Aside from helping The Staple Singers get their first recording contract, they provided a haven for jazz legend Sonny Rollins when he was beating a heroin addiction and they even influenced the Queen of Soul, Aretha Franklin, who covered one of their classics on her best-selling Amazing Grace album. This book is a genealogy on the Gay dynasty and the family business of music and ministry. However, it indirectly chronicles the hardships of a generation of gospel performers who also battled the isms of racism, chauvinism, sectarianism, and sexism. Off stage, there were battles between the sisters over romantic entanglements and business decisions. There were thieving record labels. There were prison sentences and even a murder trial. This book is a must-have for fans of traditional gospel music and for those who’d love a voyeuristic peek into twentieth-century Black church culture and the shady side of the early gospel music industry.”

Bill Carpenter, author of “Uncloudy Days: The Gospel Music Encyclopedia”

“This book is a gem. Dolins and Gay have offered a treasure trove of rich stories about gospel music, faith, and family. At times surprising, humorous, and heartbreaking, Can I Get a Witness! honors one of the most significant musical families to come out of Chicago, and opens new avenues for the study of gospel music.”

Allie Martin, author of “Intersectional Listening: Gentrification and Black Sonic Life in Washington, DC”

Table of Contents

Foreword by Sonny Rollins
Preface

1. Meeting the Gay Family and Hearing Their Story
2. Performing at Carnegie Hall
3. Moving to Chicago and Practicing the COGIC Faith
4. Changes in Gospel Music
5. Forming the Trio: The Gay Sisters
6. Recording for Dolphin, Savoy, and Decca
7. Touring the Country
8. Living at 6544 S. Champlain
9. Founding the Prayer Center
10. Visiting Memphis
11. Supporting and Accompanying the Emerging Community of Gospel Musicians
12. Supporting Mahalia Jackson
13. Making a Comeback
14. Pioneering Gospel Music on Television
15. Breaking Up and Solo Careers
16. Pastoring
17. Keeping the Prayer Center Open
18. In the Right Hands

Acknowledgments
Notes
Discography
Bibliography
Index

Be the first to know

Get the latest updates on new releases, special offers, and media highlights when you subscribe to our email lists!

Sign up here for updates about the Press